Scripture Guideby The Faith Vault
Ask the Vault
  1. Home
  2. Questions
  3. Morality
  4. What makes something right or wrong?

Morality

What makes something right or wrong?

One question. Nine perspectives. Original sources.

Hand-checked editorial pageWritten and citation-checked by Anthoney Hamrick, Founder and editor, The Faith VaultLast citation review Not yet reviewed by a scholar of every tradition — see who has, and who we are looking forReport a correction

Overview

Where does the line between right and wrong come from? The nine traditions answer in strikingly different ways. Judaism, Christianity, Islam and the Bahá'í Faith locate moral authority in God's revealed will, yet each also appeals to conscience, justice or reason. Buddhism grounds ethics in intention and consequence rather than in a lawgiver; Hinduism in dharma, the order proper to each person and situation; Sikhism in truthful living under the divine order. The Tao Te Ching treats explicit moral rules as a symptom of having lost the Way, and Shinto centres on sincerity and purity, a moral orientation practised more than codified.

Nine perspectives

Christianity

From scripture

Christian ethics rests on God's revealed will, classically summarised in the Ten Commandments and in Jesus' double command of love. Yet the prophets insist that what God requires is 'to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly', and Paul teaches that even those without the written law have its requirements 'written on their hearts', with conscience bearing witness. Catholic theology developed this into natural law; Orthodox thought emphasises conformity to Christ; Protestant traditions stress scripture and grace, and Christians debate how far reason and conscience can know right apart from revelation.

  • Exodus 20:1–17 — The Ten Commandments: God speaks the law to Israel.
  • Micah 6:8 — 'Do justice, love kindness, and walk humbly with your God.'
  • Romans 2:14–15 — The law's requirements are 'written on their hearts'; conscience bears witness.
Explore this perspective →

Islam

From scripture

In Islam right and wrong are known through God's guidance: the Qur'an and the example (Sunnah) of the Prophet, from which jurists derive the Shari'a. The Qur'an says God 'commands justice, grace, and generosity to close relatives' and 'forbids indecency, wickedness, and aggression', and it requires believers to stand for justice even against themselves or their kin. It also speaks of God inspiring the soul with knowledge of right and wrong, which theologians (Ash'ari, Maturidi and Mu'tazili, and Shi'a schools) have long debated: is something good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is good?

  • Qur'an 16:90 — God commands justice, grace and generosity; forbids indecency, wickedness, aggression.
  • Qur'an 4:135 — Stand firm for justice, even against yourselves or your parents.
  • Qur'an 91:7–8 — God fashioned the soul and inspired it with knowledge of right and wrong.
Explore this perspective →

Judaism

From scripture

Judaism locates right and wrong in the covenant: the Torah's commandments (mitzvot) as interpreted through halakha, the ongoing rabbinic legal tradition. Deuteronomy insists the commandment is not far off in heaven but 'very close to you, in your mouth and in your heart'. The Mishnah in Pirkei Avot warns to treat a light commandment as carefully as a grave one, and the Talmud records Hillel's summary of the whole Torah: what is hateful to you, do not do to another. Orthodox, Conservative and Reform Judaism differ over how binding halakha is and how it changes, but share the conviction that ethics is lived out in concrete obligations.

Explore this perspective →

Buddhism

From scripture

Buddhism grounds ethics in kamma (karma): actions rooted in greed, hatred and delusion lead to suffering, and those rooted in their opposites lead to well-being. The Dhammapada opens by saying that mind precedes all states, so speaking or acting with an impure mind brings suffering and with a pure mind brings happiness. In the Kalama Sutta the Buddha tells his listeners not to rely on tradition, scripture or teachers alone but to know for themselves which things are skilful and blameless and lead to welfare. He also instructs his son Rahula to examine every action beforehand, during and afterwards for whether it harms oneself or others. The five precepts express this as basic training for lay life.

Explore this perspective →

Hinduism

From scripture

Hindu ethics is organised around dharma, the right order of things and the duty proper to a person's stage of life, role and situation (svadharma). The Bhagavad Gita says it is better to perform one's own duty imperfectly than another's perfectly, and that acting according to one's innate duty incurs no sin. When in doubt, Krishna directs Arjuna to let the scriptures be his authority for what should and should not be done. Dharma also has universal components (sadharana dharma) such as non-violence, truthfulness and compassion, and different schools weigh scriptural injunction, tradition and the conscience of the good differently.

Explore this perspective →

Sikhism

From scripture

Guru Nanak's line in Siri Raag is the touchstone: 'Truth is higher than everything; but higher still is truthful living.' Right action flows from living in accord with Hukam, the divine order, and from overcoming the five vices (lust, anger, greed, attachment, ego). Nanak also gives a practical test on Ang 1245: one who works for what he eats and gives some of what he has 'knows the Path'. Sikh ethics is thus less a code than a way of honest work, sharing and remembrance of God (kirat karni, vand chhakna, naam japna), with the Rehat Maryada later codifying communal discipline.

Explore this perspective →

Bahá'í Faith

From scripture

The Bahá'í writings ground morality in God's revelation through his Manifestations while also naming justice as a faculty of personal moral sight. The second Arabic Hidden Word calls justice 'the best beloved of all things' in God's sight, by whose aid a person 'shall see with thine own eyes and not through the eyes of others'. The Kitáb-i-Aqdas, Bahá'u'lláh's book of laws, makes recognition of God's Messenger the first duty and the observance of his ordinances inseparable from it, and frames obedience as an act of love: 'Observe My commandments, for the love of My beauty.' Bahá'ís also hold that moral law evolves as humanity matures, so each revelation renews it.

Explore this perspective →

Taoism

From scripture

The Tao Te Ching is suspicious of morality as a set of explicit rules. Chapter 18 says that when the great Tao ceased to be observed, benevolence and righteousness 'came into vogue', and chapter 38 traces a decline from the Tao to virtue, then to benevolence, righteousness and finally propriety, which it calls the beginning of disorder. Chapter 57 adds that the more laws are displayed, the more thieves there are. Right action is wu wei, spontaneous accord with the Way, from which genuine goodness arises unforced. Later religious Taoism did develop precepts and moral ledgers, but the classical text prizes naturalness over codes.

  • Tao Te Ching 38 — When the Tao was lost, virtue, then benevolence, righteousness and propriety appeared.
  • Tao Te Ching 18 — When the great Tao ceased to be observed, benevolence and righteousness came into vogue.
  • Tao Te Ching 57 — 'The more display there is of legislation, the more thieves and robbers there are.'
Explore this perspective →

Shinto

Expressed through practice — no direct text

Shinto has no revealed moral code and expresses its ethics chiefly through practice. Its cardinal virtue is makoto, sincerity or 'a heart free of falsehood', and its central negative category is kegare, pollution, together with tsumi, transgression, both of which are removed through harae (purification) and misogi (ablution). Wrong is understood less as breaking a rule than as disturbing harmony between people and kami; setting things right is a matter of cleansing and renewed sincerity. Sect Shinto groups and modern Shinto thinkers have articulated fuller ethical teachings, but shrine Shinto remains largely practice-based.

Explore this perspective →

Where traditions overlap

  • Every tradition treats how one acts toward others as a moral matter with real consequences, whether judged by God, by kamma, or by harmony with the order of things.
  • Several theistic traditions appeal both to revealed command and to an inner faculty: conscience in Paul, the inspired soul in the Qur'an, justice as one's own sight in the Hidden Words, the commandment 'in your heart' in Deuteronomy.
  • Buddhism, Sikhism and Micah all make a similar move from rule to character: what counts is the state of mind, truthful living, or justice and kindness rather than observance alone.

Where they differ

  • Judaism, Islam and the Bahá'í Faith give detailed revealed law a central place; the Kalama Sutta and the Tao Te Ching are wary of relying on authority and codes.
  • Buddhism locates rightness in intention and consequence without a divine lawgiver; Hinduism ties it to dharma that varies with a person's role and situation.
  • Shinto frames wrongdoing as pollution to be purified rather than as guilt before a law, and has no scriptural code.

Sources

TraditionPassageSummary
ChristianityExodus 20:1–17
Bible Gateway, NRSVue
The Ten Commandments: God speaks the law to Israel.
ChristianityMicah 6:8
Bible Gateway, NRSVue
'Do justice, love kindness, and walk humbly with your God.'
ChristianityRomans 2:14–15
Bible Gateway, NRSVue
The law's requirements are 'written on their hearts'; conscience bears witness.
IslamQur'an 16:90
Quran.com
God commands justice, grace and generosity; forbids indecency, wickedness, aggression.
IslamQur'an 4:135
Quran.com
Stand firm for justice, even against yourselves or your parents.
IslamQur'an 91:7–8
Quran.com
God fashioned the soul and inspired it with knowledge of right and wrong.
JudaismDeuteronomy 30:11–14
Sefaria
The commandment is 'very close to you, in your mouth and in your heart'.
JudaismPirkei Avot 2:1
Sefaria
Be as careful with a light commandment as with a grave one.
JudaismTalmud, Shabbat 31a
Sefaria
Hillel: 'That which is hateful to you do not do to another.'
BuddhismKalama Sutta (AN 3.65)
SuttaCentral, Sujato
Know for yourselves what is skilful, blameless and leads to welfare.
BuddhismAmbalatthika Rahulovada Sutta (MN 61)
SuttaCentral, Sujato
Check each action: does it lead to hurting myself or others?
BuddhismDhammapada 1–2
Access to Insight, Buddharakkhita
Mind precedes all; impure mind brings suffering, pure mind happiness.
HinduismBhagavad Gita 16:24
Holy Bhagavad Gita, Mukundananda
Let the scriptures be your authority for what should and should not be done.
HinduismBhagavad Gita 18:47
Holy Bhagavad Gita, Mukundananda
Better one's own dharma imperfectly than another's perfectly.
HinduismBhagavad Gita 3:35
Holy Bhagavad Gita, Mukundananda
Perform your own prescribed duty, though tinged with faults.
SikhismGuru Granth Sahib, Ang 62 (Guru Nanak)
SikhiToTheMax
'Truth is higher than everything; but higher still is truthful living.'
SikhismGuru Granth Sahib, Ang 1245 (Guru Nanak)
SikhiToTheMax
One who works for what he eats and shares 'knows the Path'.
Bahá'í FaithHidden Words, Arabic 2
Bahá'í Reference Library
Justice is 'the best beloved of all things'; see with your own eyes.
Bahá'í FaithKitáb-i-Aqdas ¶1
Bahá'í Reference Library
First duty: recognise God's Messenger and observe every ordinance.
Bahá'í FaithKitáb-i-Aqdas ¶4
Bahá'í Reference Library
'Observe My commandments, for the love of My beauty.'
TaoismTao Te Ching 38
ctext.org, Legge
When the Tao was lost, virtue, then benevolence, righteousness and propriety appeared.
TaoismTao Te Ching 18
ctext.org, Legge
When the great Tao ceased to be observed, benevolence and righteousness came into vogue.
TaoismTao Te Ching 57
ctext.org, Legge
'The more display there is of legislation, the more thieves and robbers there are.'
ShintoEncyclopedia of Shinto — 'Makoto'
Encyclopedia of Shinto, Kokugakuin
Sincerity, 'a heart free of falsehood', one of Shinto's cardinal virtues.
ShintoEncyclopedia of Shinto — 'Kegare'
Encyclopedia of Shinto, Kokugakuin
Pollution, the opposite of purity; distinguished from tsumi (transgression).
ShintoEncyclopedia of Shinto — 'Harae'
Encyclopedia of Shinto, Kokugakuin
Purification of mind and body from accumulated sins and defilements.

All citations on this page were opened in the linked reference editions and compared with the summaries (last full pass September 12, 2026). Links open at the verse, paragraph or section wherever the edition supports it; otherwise at the chapter or entry. Translations vary; we link to widely used public editions so you can compare. Evidence labels on each perspective follow our editorial standards.

Frequently asked questions

Do all religions say morality comes from God?

No. Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Sikhism and the Bahá'í Faith ground it in God's will or order, but Buddhism grounds ethics in intention and kamma, the Tao Te Ching in accord with the Tao, and Shinto in sincerity and purity, none of which require a divine lawgiver.

Is there a version of the Golden Rule in these traditions?

Yes, in several forms: Hillel's 'what is hateful to you do not do to another' (Shabbat 31a), Jesus' 'love your neighbour as yourself', the Buddha's test of whether an action hurts oneself or others (MN 61), and Farid's counsel in the Guru Granth Sahib not to break anyone's heart.

Why does the Tao Te Ching criticise virtue?

It does not oppose goodness but argues (chapters 18 and 38) that explicit rules of benevolence, righteousness and propriety only appear once natural accord with the Tao has been lost; genuine goodness is spontaneous rather than legislated.

Go deeper

Ask the Vault your own version of this question

Answers are AI-assisted, drawn from nine traditions and linked to original sources. No account needed.

The Scripture Guide uses artificial intelligence to help organize and explain religious texts and traditions. AI-generated responses may contain errors or omissions. When accuracy is important, consult the original scripture and authoritative sources.